Eleuthera, Bahamas – May 2015

Almost 2 more years go by until I visit the Caribbean again. I had quit my job as a dental assistant, went back to school, started my own business, and was able to travel again. My husband and I were trying to find somewhere to go. We wanted to go back to Jamaica because he had fallen in love with it too. But I had been twice and I was eager to go somewhere else. We were researching and researching. We still had the idea of all inclusive in our heads because it was basically all we had known. Then a highschool friend had just went to the Bahamas and was sharing her photos on Facebook. This place was magical.  I had only known of the touristy Bahamas. Nassau, Freeport, Atlantis. You know, everything most people know of in the Bahamas. But what Bahamas is this in my friend’s photos?? I must know. Surely though it is out of our budget. This place was too beautiful for us to afford. But I take a chance that it could possibly, hopefully fall in our budget and message her. She gives me all the info. This magical place is called Eleuthera, Bahamas. I had never heard of it. I started Googling. I am in love. She gives me the name and contact info of the place she and her husband stayed which is Edge of the World Properties and tells me the price. I am floored. This is most definitely in budget. I cannot believe it. The property itself is pure heaven. This is also where we pretty much break up with the all inclusives. But I’ll get to that later.

I contact Edge of the World Properties. They basically operate off of referrals and most of their advertising is done through their FaceBook page. The cottages are owned by Kimy and Terry Johnson and they are both awesome. Kimy still keeps in touch with me til this day. Anyway, we book it. We end up reserving the Tamarind Tree Cottage which at the time was $1100 for a week in May. I do not believe the price has gone up at the time of this writing. I start showing my parents photos of this magical place called Eleuthera, Bahamas and tell them the price and details. My dad now wants to go! So after talking it over with my mom, he tells me to book one of the other cottages. So I book the Seahorse Cottage for them. I believe the price for it was $1200 for the week. Family trip!

Our vacation time finally arrives. Just worth mentioning but Delta now offers nonstop flights to Eleuthera from some airports, including Atlanta, but at the time we went it did not. So we drove 3 hours from home to Atlanta, flew out of Atlanta and a layover in Miami. The flight was short from Miami. I think around 30-45 minutes. We land in Eleuthera and it is the smallest airport I have personally seen to date. Customs was quick and we were on our way by taxi to Edge of the World Properties.

As we get out onto the property located up on a hill over looking a cove in Gregory Town, we are greeted by Kimy, Terry, and Morocco (their sweet dog). Our cottage is small and quaint but all we need and the property is more gorgeous than the photos. I walk down to the water and literally ask my husband to pinch me. I had never seen water so beautiful. It was the most beautiful shade of turquoise I had ever laid my eyes on. I was in tears of joy. And now even more obsessed with the Caribbean than I was before if that is even possible.

Eleuthera is a small, friendly island. The people are so friendly that I need to tell this story to get my point across how friendly they are. We did not realize we would need to rent a car to get around and the day after we arrived was Mother’s Day and we were informed nothing would be open. D’Oh! So we were eating at a little place called Unca Gene’s which was within walking distance of the our cottages. We asked the owner if she would be open and she said very few things would be open and that they would be closed as well. We explained we didn’t have a rental car yet and wasn’t sure what we were going to do. She then offered to let us borrow her car! She said she would be visiting her mom in Nassau and would not be using it. What?? As wonderful as that was, we could not take her up on that offer. She tried to get us to, but I just could not. It is not the way I am wired. But the offer was more than appreciated. We ended up walking to the convenience store that night and getting some quick eats to cook the following day. After that, we rented a car for the duration of our stay. Made things much easier since most things are spread out and not within walking distance. We now book rental cars in advance if needed! Ha! (BTW, I recommend the conch bites at Unca Gene’s. We ate them almost every day as a snack). 

Eleuthera is a must visit. It was the most unique experience. There are no food chains, no chains of any kind. No big, lavish resorts taking up most of the beautiful, natural land. In fact, we found the restaurants in general to be far and few between. Be sure to bring cash, we only found 2 restaurants that take credit card. US dollar is widely accepted so no need to exchange currency if you are visiting from the US. It is not a foodie paradise, but in all other senses, it definitely is. It is where we discovered our love for conch. If you ever visit, look for the conch stand on the side of the road in James Cistern. Get the tropical conch salad. You will thank me. It is the best conch salad I have ever eaten and I have had a many conch salads at this point. It is where I found my love of sea food. It is where my husband and I found our love of snorkeling.

There are many things I can recommend to do in Eleuthera. Glass window bridge, Preacher’s Cave, and Queen’s Bath are just among the many things to see. But your best bet is to rent a car or hitchhike and ask the locals. There are no street signs but just about any road will lead you to a deserted, beautiful postcard perfect beach.

Links to our YouTube photos and videos: